The DIY impulse runs deep in business culture. If something can be built with off-the-shelf parts, someone will try. Door locks, cameras, even access control systems have become the target of this instinct. Buy a cheap reader, order bulk credentials online, and you have a working setup. Or at least something that looks like one.
The appeal is obvious. It feels cheaper. It feels flexible. It feels like control. But beneath that first layer of savings lies risk. Access control is not just about opening doors. It is about security, reliability, audit trails, and long-term value. The DIY approach often misses those layers. Professionally designed cards, particularly proximity cards, provide what pieced-together systems cannot: resilience, standard compliance, and trust.
The DIY Attraction
Photo credit
Low Entry Cost
Retailers sell card readers for less than the price of dinner. Packs of unbranded cards ship in days. For landlords, small business owners, or entrepreneurs running co-working spaces, it looks like an obvious win.
The Illusion of Control
DIY setups give the impression that everything is in the owner’s hands. Buy parts, configure them, issue credentials. It feels empowering.
The Problem
Security is rarely about what looks functional. It is about what actually stands up to misuse, error, and attack. A cheap lock keeps out casual intruders. A strong system keeps out everyone else.
Why Proximity Cards Became the Standard
Proximity cards, based on RFID technology, are now the baseline for modern access systems. They use contactless communication, allowing a card to be read within a few centimeters. No swiping, no physical wear. Just presence.
Standards like ISO/IEC 14443 and 15693 govern the technical specifications of proximity and vicinity cards, ensuring global interoperability (ISO/IEC 14443-1; ISO/IEC 15693-1). These standards exist to guarantee performance and security across implementations. DIY setups often ignore or poorly implement these guidelines.
Security Is a System, Not a Part
NIST describes physical access control systems (PACS) as integrated environments where credentials, readers, controllers, and policies work together (NIST SP 800-116r1). A card by itself is not secure. A reader by itself is not secure. Security emerges from how the pieces interact.
DIY often means buying mismatched parts. A no-name reader paired with generic credentials. The system functions, but it lacks layered safeguards like encryption, key diversification, and central revocation. Professional cards are built into systems that assume risk and design against it.
The Cost of Weak Credentials
Cloning Risks
Academic research has documented cloning attacks against legacy proximity technologies such as MIFARE Classic. Garcia et al. showed how cards could be copied with off-the-shelf hardware.
Cheap cards often still use these outdated protocols. A cloned card bypasses every other layer of security if the system does not catch it.
No Audit Trail
Professional setups log card activity. Who entered, when, and through which door. That audit trail is critical for both security investigations and compliance. DIY systems frequently skip this. The result is doors that open but no accountability.
The Hidden Costs of DIY
Replacement and Maintenance
Cheap cards break. Readers fail. Firmware is unsupported. Over time, businesses spend more replacing broken parts than they would have on professional systems upfront.
Liability
A breach due to cloned or stolen cards exposes businesses to financial and legal consequences. Insurance providers increasingly expect security systems to follow industry standards. Cutting corners is not just risky. It can be costly in claims and reputation.
Time
Entrepreneurs often underestimate the time required to manage a DIY system. Issuing, deactivating, and replacing cards without centralized software becomes an administrative burden.
Why Professionally Designed Cards Endure
Professionally designed proximity cards are not just plastic with chips. They are engineered to meet standards, resist common attacks, and integrate with enterprise-level software.
- Encryption: Modern cards use strong encryption protocols, making cloning far harder.
- Durability: Cards are designed to last for years, not months.
- Compatibility: Cards work with established access ecosystems that scale with business growth.
- Revocation: Lost cards can be deactivated instantly without affecting the rest of the system.
These features are invisible in daily use. But they are critical when something goes wrong.
The Business Layer
Proximity cards do more than open doors. They integrate with time tracking, payroll, and resource management systems. They can control access to printers, data centers, and labs. They create a unified identity system across an organization.
DIY systems rarely scale into this ecosystem. They remain limited to opening and closing. Professional systems create value by expanding functionality.
The ROI Argument
Entrepreneurs think in returns. The ROI of proximity cards is not just about reduced theft or break-ins. It is about efficiency. Faster throughput at doors saves time. Audit trails reduce investigation costs. Centralized management saves admin hours. Long-lasting cards reduce replacement cycles.
A 2018 IFSEC Global report noted that integrated access control systems save organizations significant operational costs by reducing downtime and streamlining staff management (IFSEC Global). That is ROI that DIY cannot replicate.
The Human Factor
Employees and tenants notice the difference. A card that works every time builds trust. A system that fails creates frustration and workarounds. Propped doors and shared codes are not just annoying. They are security risks.
Security culture is shaped by reliability. Professionally designed cards support that culture. DIY undermines it.
The Role of Providers
Behind every reliable system is a provider who understands standards, threats, and integration. Businesses turn to suppliers of proximity cards because these systems are not one-off purchases. They are infrastructure. Providers bring the expertise that DIY cannot.
Conclusion
DIY access control is tempting. It looks cheap, fast, and flexible. But the hidden costs in risk, maintenance, and liability outweigh the savings. Professionally designed proximity cards and readers remain the backbone of secure, scalable systems. They endure not because they are glamorous but because they deliver consistency, trust, and value.
Entrepreneurs know that passive income depends on reliable infrastructure. Locks and access control are part of that foundation. Doors should open easily for the right people and never for the wrong ones. That is not a place to cut corners.
